Monday, 11 May 2015

Friday's crit peer feedback

Fridays crit.
I got a lot of feedback that I will definitely take into account and work to. The improvements given have been really helpful of what specific things that I should do to help my module.


General feedback:



  • Wonderful colour palette, seems very refined and well selected.
  • Love it, consistent.
  • Really interesting idea.
  • Really cool idea and nice palette. Also really useful, are you producing books?
  • Really well crafted images.
  • Great uniformity across the pages.
  • Really well drawn scenes- you nailed the perspective.
  • Nice resolutions, crisp yet wispy and gestural. Good balance.
Peer review feedback:
Demonstrate an informed understanding of issues relating to media, communication, audience and context through the delivery of solutions to brief led problems or clearly identified creative concerns. (Knowledge &Understanding - Critical Awareness)

Strengths
- Evidence of contextual research
- Good body of work both in quality and size

Improvements
- Needs some more annotation on research findings
-Additional blog posts needed on development stages.



Understand the potential and limitations of technologies and processes used in the production of illustration for 2d,3d and/or 4d distribution. (Knowledge and Understanding - Research)

Strengths
  • considered layout of book, evidenced how it would work on a spread
  • evidence of how it would look on products such as a bottle packaging in early development
Improvements


  • document evidence of researching the technologies involved in book binding and printing

Analyse and critically evaluate the impact of social, cultural, technological and/or ethical concerns on the development of solutions to problems relevant to individual creative concerns.
(Cognitive Skills - Problem Analysis, Problem Solving)

Strengths
  • considered audience and why illustration are appropriate in book format
Improvements


  • target audience down to who exactly it is in the individual blog post.
  • consider environmental impact
  • consider a mock ebook
Explore and apply a range of appropriate practical and conceptual approaches to self-determined ideas, concepts, solutions/proposals in response to own identified intentions and relevant practices. (Practical Skills - Practical and Conceptual Development)

Strengths
  • considered different styles and formats (bottle to book)
Improvements
  • Document how text/type developed

Produce technically competent and conceptually appropriate outcomes to identified problems through the selection and application of visual skills. (Practical Skills - Visual Quality and Technical Competence)

Strengths
  • thought gone into colour, style and format
Improvements
  • perhaps show experimentation with different paper stocks to see which works best
  • consider handwritten cover

Demonstrate the ability to plan and carry out a period of increasingly self-directed study through the appropriate use of workshop areas, studio activity and project management skills.
(key transferable Skills - Presentation and Evaluation)

Strengths
  • well time tabled
  • boards clear and easy to read
Improvements
  • catch u with blogging

General Comments
  • more research on the manufacture of books to the level of research of bottled ginger beer

No comments:

Post a Comment